Discussion

Search code, repositories, users, issues, pull requests...

EmilStenstrom: Here is the link to the blogpost, that actually describe what this is: https://github.com/google-research/timesfm?tab=readme-ov-fil...

Foobar8568: Somehow I missed that one. Are there any competition on this?I always had difficulties with ML and time series, I'll need to try that out.

refulgentis: That takes me to the same content as the submission, a GitHub repo (Chrome on iOS)

EmilStenstrom: I somehow find the concept of a general time series model strange. How can the same model predict egg prices in Italy, and global inflation in a reliable way?And how would you even use this model, given that there are no explanations that help you trust where the prediction comes from…

benob: I would say:- decomposition: discover a more general form of Fourrier transform to untangle the underlying factors- memorization: some patterns are recurrent in many domains such as power low- multitask: exploit cross-domain connections such as weather vs electricity

rockwotj: https://www.datadoghq.com/blog/datadog-time-series-foundatio...https://moment-timeseries-foundation-model.github.io/https://arxiv.org/abs/2403.07815A friend at work used one to predict when our CEO would post in Slack, which is verry entertaining to see if correct.

rockwotj: Probably the better link: https://research.google/blog/a-decoder-only-foundation-model...

akshayshah: And https://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10688 if you want the full paper.

Cyuonut: I suppose they tried to link this: https://research.google/blog/a-decoder-only-foundation-model...

nels: I think you meant to link this page: https://research.google/blog/a-decoder-only-foundation-model...

teruakohatu: What is not generally understood is that these models don’t predict egg prices or inflation in Italy.They decompose a time series into trends, seasonality and residuals. That’s what they are actually modelling.They cannot predict wars in the Middle East influencing inflation unless there is a seasonal pattern(s).

lovelearning: My understanding is that the synthetic training data helps capture abstract time-series patterns that are common in all domains.As they say in appendix 8:> We create the synthetic data to reflect common time-series patterns using traditional statistical models. We start with four simple times series patterns:> • Piece-wise linear trends (I), where the number of the piece-wise linear components is randomly chosen between 2 and 8.> • ARMA(p, q) (II), where 1 ≤ p, q ≤ 8 and the corresponding coefficients are generated from either a multivariate Gaussian or a uniform, then normalized.> • Seasonal patterns. In particular we create the sine (III) and the cosine (IV) waves of different random periods between 4 and max context length / 2 time-points and time delays.If there were no such underlying patterns in the class of time-series data, then even traditional time-series models would be fundamentally misplaced.And since this is a transformer model, it also looks for patterns in the problem-specific input data at inference time, just like how the input context to an LLM influences its output's relevance.

cybrox: Wars in the middle east seem to have increasingly regular patterns tied to stock market opening hours, unfortunately.

d--b: The main issue is that people do use them to predict bitcoin prices intraday and that sort of things.

visarga: ARIMA and ARMA models

wiradikusuma: Also: https://github.com/Nixtla/nixtla and https://facebook.github.io/prophet/

nico: Is it an issue because it works, or because it doesn’t? Or because it’s bitcoin?I genuinely want to know. Thank you

dash2: So the time series are provided with no context? It's just trained on lots of sets of numbers? Then you give it a new set of numbers and it guesses the rest, again with no context?My guess as to how this would work: the machine will first guess from the data alone if this is one of the categories it has already seen/inferred (share prices, google trend cat searches etc.) Then it'll output a plausible completion for the category.That doesn't seem as if it will work well for any categories outside the training data. I would rather just use either a simple model (ARIMA or whatever) or a theoretically-informed model. But what do I know.

jdthedisciple: Let me be blunt: Shannon would tell us that time forecasting is bullshit:There is infinitely more entropy in the real world out there than any model can even remotely capture.The world is not minecraft.

ra: [delayed]

mikkom: Yeah all weather forecasts are just magic

eru: > How can the same model predict egg prices in Italy, and global inflation in a reliable way?How can the same lossy compression algorithm (eg JPG) compress pictures of everything in a reliable way?

cenamus: It can't compress pictures of everything in a reliable way.Text and anything with lots of high frequency components looks terrible

rubyn00bie: I totally agree with the sentiment but from what I can tell, I’d say they tend happen immediately before or after markets open and close. Essentially, and to their maximum, screwing absolutely everyone who isn’t in the clique from participating in the trade.FWIW— the only sure fire way to win the trade is to buy time and assume both gross incompetence and negligence when it comes action. The only caveat is if the markets tank enough, this administration will signal capitulation before hand, e.g. Trump mildly capitulating on tariffs last April after the markets proceed to relentlessly defecate themselves.0-DTE options are typically, and for good reason, stupid gambles. But, right now they can’t even be considered gambling, because there’s zero chance of winning. Not just bad odds, but no odds. Again just signaling how truly malicious this admin is and its disdain for anyone and everyone not close to them.

eru: And JPG doesn't work either..

tgv: Weather forecasts are notoriously iffy, and accuracy drops with time, but we understand the physics behind it (to a large extent). There's also a lot of fine-grained data available. For some arbitrary time series, there's only one data sequence, and the model is unknown. Extrapolation then becomes a lot more magical.

raghavMultilipi: This has been around a few months now, has anyone built anything on it?

kgwgk: Whether forecasting is simple: it either rains or it doesn’t. 50/50 probability!

at_compile_time: Reliably terrible.