Discussion
Search code, repositories, users, issues, pull requests...
Luka12-dev: Author here! Happy to answer any questions about the implementation.
sourcegrift: No offense, and God forbid I sound like a "fanboy" but I'd highly recommend using Rust or Zig instead of c for the rest of your project. I appreciate C and assembly and am pretty "conservative" in my choices of PL but both rust and zig, despite having their own disadvantages, and also a slightly unpleasant community based on where you come from, are actually plain better than C in every respect. The abstractions are 0 cost and often pretty "transparent" so you know exactly what's happening behind the scenes.
toast0: 0> RTL8139 network driver (WIP)It's good to have support for real networking hardware, but consider virtio-net as well. A lot of VMs support it and it's more streamlined. 32-bit x86, bios boot means doing a lot of things for compatibility with systems that were old enough to drink before you were born... skipping to simplified virtualized interfaces wherever possible makes a lot of sense; even if your OS can run in 16 MB of ram, you're probably not going to run it on a 486 with 16 MB of RAM and a real parallel IDE drive ... at least not at first. You can always come back and make that work if you want... deferring tricky things until later so you can work on the fun stuff keeps you having fun and engaged with your project.Also, consider trying to get your OS running on v86. It's fun having your hobby OS work in a browser. The biggest limitations I've run into are 32-bit x86 only, single processor only; but those might not be that big of a deal... looks like your OS is also 32-bit x86 only, and I don't see anything about SMP in your project. If there's anything missing from v86 that you depend on, I've had a wonderful experience with submitting PRs; copy often reworks my patches to be much better before applying them, which I always appreciate rather than a back and forth attempt to get me to make it better :)PS 12 hour days are a lot; hope you're getting all your other stuff done :P
joexbayer: Very cool! Would suggest https://oshub.org/explore if youre interested in hobby operating systems.
Luka12-dev: Thanks for the suggestion! I've heard great things about both Rust and Zig for systems programming.I started with C because most osdev resources and tutorials use C, and I wanted to understand manual memory management at the lowest level first.Might explore rewriting parts in Rust or Zig in the future, the safety guarantees do sound appealing for kernel code!
cyberax: How much was built with the AI? An OS is definitely a fun project and the classic x86 is a pretty good platform for that!
Luka12-dev: I wrote the core architecture and most of the code myself. I used Claude occasionally to help debug tricky issues and understand some concepts, but the design decisions and implementation are mine.I think AI is a great learning tool when you're trying to understand low-level concepts for the first time.
gmueckl: How did you decide between assembler and C for various parts of the kernel? Some choices are very different from what I would have picked, so I'm curious about your thought process.
Luka12-dev: My general rule was:Assembly for anything that HAS to be assembly: bootloader, GDT/IDT setup, interrupt handlers, context switching, and port I/O wrappers.C for everything else: window manager, apps, drivers, GUI rendering.Some parts I probably could have done in C with inline assembly but I found writing pure ASM for the low-level stuff helped me understand exactly what was happening at the hardware level.What choices looked different to you? I'd love to hear your perspective always looking to improve!
jackpeterfletch: AI Account.Everything in that account has appeared in the last 6mo. Very unnatural commit activity, and clearly contradicts the claim that this is their first OS project. Is linked to a faceless YT channel.
Luka12-dev: Fair question! I understand the skepticism.The account is newer because I only recently started putting my projects on GitHub. I've been programming in C and Assembly for a while before that, just locally on my machine.The commit activity might look unusual because I worked in very intense 12h/day sprints over 14 days.As for AI, I'm happy to do a live walkthrough of any part of the codebase, explain the design decisions, or answer any specific technical questions about the implementation.I appreciate the scrutiny though it keeps the community honest!
apitman: I disagree. Rust and Zig bring millions of lines of code of dependencies and complexity in their toolchains. We can hope for a relatively simple Zig compiler someday, but not Rust. If you care about portability (now and in the future), C is a much better choice.
d--b: https://github.com/Luka12-devsigh
