Discussion

Search code, repositories, users, issues, pull requests...

esperent: [delayed]

renewiltord: Yeah, all the claw based agents use similar structure. I experimented a little with SQLite DB with embedding so it could vector search but I did not manage to get it to do better. Best is still to just stuff things in context and let it full text search history.

bigbezet: A lot of devs, including me, have tried something similar already. I don't really find this approach reliable.Firstly, tools like Claude Code already have things like auto memory.Secondly, I think we all learned by now that agents will not always reliably follow instructions in the AGENTS.md file, especially as the size of the context increases. If we want to guarantee that something happens, we should use hooks.There are already solutions to track what the agent did and even summarising it without affecting the context window of the agent. Tools like Claude Code log activity in a way which is possible to analyze, so you can use tools to process that.When I tried something similar in the past, the agent would not really understand what is important to "memorise" in a KNOWLEDGE.md file, and would create a lot of bloat which I would then need to clean up anyway.There are existing tools to tell the agent what has happened recently: git. By looking at the commit messages and list of changed files, the agent usually gets most of the information it needs. If there are any very important decisions or learnings which are necessary for the agent to understand more, they should be written down >manually< by a developer, as I don't trust the agent to decide that.Also, there is an ongoing discussion about whether AGENTS.md files are even needed, or whether they should be kept to an absolute minimum. Despite what we all initially thought, those files can actually negatively affect the output, based on recent research.

_pdp_: > AI agents already read AGENTS.md (or CLAUDE.md, .cursorrules, etc.) as project instructions. This kernel uses that mechanism to teach the agent how to remember.Dude, this is just prompts. It is as useful as asking claude code to write these files itself.